The 1995 NAIA Football All-American Team was selected by the NAIA Football Coaches. The list below does not designate between first and second team All-American honors from the NAIA. This information comes directly from NAIAHonors.com
| Alphonso Harris | Football | 1995 | All-American | Southern Oregon University |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Andy Harold | Football | 1995 | All-American | University of Sioux Falls |
| Andy Lwanga | Football | 1995 | All-American | Central Washington |
| Anthony Williams | Football | 1995 | All-American | Arkansas-Pine Bluff |
| Art Cadena | Football | 1995 | All-American | Ouachita Baptist (Ark.) |
| Barry Meyer | Football | 1995 | All-American | Westmar (Iowa) |
| Ben Elliot | Football | 1995 | All-American | Bethany College |
| Ben Elliott | Football | 1995 | All-American | Bethany College |
| Bob Cole | Football | 1995 | All-American | Northeastern Oklahoma State |
| Bryan Bonander | Football | 1995 | All-American | Western Montana |
| Cal Dietz | Football | 1995 | All-American | Findlay (Ohio) |
| Cedric Doolittle | Football | 1995 | All-American | Arkansas-Pine Bluff |
| Chad Griffin | Football | 1995 | All-American | Harding (Ark.) |
| Chad Kraemer | Football | 1995 | All-American | Western New Mexico |
| Chad McCollam | Football | 1995 | All-American | Georgetown College |
| Charles Burrell | Football | 1995 | All-American | Arkansas-Pine Bluff |
| Chenelle Jones | Football | 1995 | All-American | Western New Mexico |
| Chip Joecken | Football | 1995 | All-American | Northwestern College |
| Corby Walker | Football | 1995 | All-American | Midwestern State (Texas) |
| Cory Stevens | Football | 1995 | All-American | Minot State University |
| Craig Derr | Football | 1995 | All-American | Tiffin (Ohio) |
| Craig Mills | Football | 1995 | All-American | Westminster (Pa.) |
| Damont Skanes | Football | 1995 | All-American | Walsh University |
| Dan Ruch | Football | 1995 | All-American | Benedictine College |
| Daryl Wright | Football | 1995 | All-American | Puget Sound (Wash.) |
| DeAuntae Brown | Football | 1995 | All-American | Central State (Ohio) |
| Demillo Bynum | Football | 1995 | All-American | Langston University |
| Derrick Sanders | Football | 1995 | All-American | Minnesota-Crookston |
| Dimitrius Coleman | Football | 1995 | All-American | Trinity International University |
| Don Fellows | Football | 1995 | All-American | Huron (S.D.) |
| Doug Kraft | Football | 1995 | All-American | Huron (S.D.) |
| Duane Monlux | Football | 1995 | All-American | Dickinson State University |
| Eric Nuber | Football | 1995 | All-American | Southeastern Oklahoma |
| Ervin Whitehead | Football | 1995 | All-American | Westmar (Iowa) |
| Frank Beede | Football | 1995 | All-American | Oklahoma Panhandle State University |
| Gavin Stanley | Football | 1995 | All-American | Pacific Lutheran (Wash.) |
| Gilbert Jenkins | Football | 1995 | All-American | Western New Mexico |
| Gordon Smith | Football | 1995 | All-American | Northwestern Oklahoma State University |
| Greg Terpstra | Football | 1995 | All-American | Northwestern College |
| Greg Thomas | Football | 1995 | All-American | Clinch Valley (Va.) |
| Henry Johnson | Football | 1995 | All-American | Midwestern State (Texas) |
| Isaia Isaia | Football | 1995 | All-American | Baker University |
| J.J. Guedet | Football | 1995 | All-American | Taylor University |
| J.J. Lamb | Football | 1995 | All-American | Carroll College |
| J.J. Thigpen | Football | 1995 | All-American | Oklahoma Panhandle State University |
| Jake Petersen | Football | 1995 | All-American | Montana Technological University |
| Jake Wiersman | Football | 1995 | All-American | Azusa Pacific University |
| James Martin | Football | 1995 | All-American | East Central (Okla.) |
| Jase Bradford | Football | 1995 | All-American | Lambuth University |
| Jason Cecil | Football | 1995 | All-American | Northwestern Oklahoma State University |
| Jason DesJarlais | Football | 1995 | All-American | Western Montana |
| Jason Hall | Football | 1995 | All-American | Hardin-Simmons (Texas) |
| Jason Truman | Football | 1995 | All-American | Western Montana |
| Jeff Moser | Football | 1995 | All-American | Southeastern Oklahoma |
| Jeton Cooper | Football | 1995 | All-American | Northwestern Oklahoma State University |
| Joel Heineman | Football | 1995 | All-American | Westmar (Iowa) |
| John Fey | Football | 1995 | All-American | Union Commonwealth University |
| Jon Kitna | Football | 1995 | All-American | Central Washington |
| Junior Lowden | Football | 1995 | All-American | Southwestern Oklahoma State |
| Junior Lowden | Football | 1995 | All-American | Southwest Oklahoma |
| Karl Lerum | Football | 1995 | All-American | Pacific Lutheran (Wash.) |
| Kenny Jenkins | Football | 1995 | All-American | Langston University |
| Kenny Russaw | Football | 1995 | All-American | Central Washington |
| Kenny Russow | Football | 1995 | All-American | Central Washington |
| Kevin Sheahan | Football | 1995 | All-American | Carroll College |
| Lamar Lowe | Football | 1995 | All-American | Southeastern Oklahoma |
| Lamark Brim | Football | 1995 | All-American | Langston University |
| Lance Baatz | Football | 1995 | All-American | Northwestern College |
| Leonta Gillespie | Football | 1995 | All-American | Arkansas-Pine Bluff |
| Lionel Porter | Football | 1995 | All-American | St. Ambrose University |
| Mae Hawsey | Football | 1995 | All-American | Austin (Texas) |
| Mitch Green | Football | 1995 | All-American | Northeastern Oklahoma State |
| Moses Sherman | Football | 1995 | All-American | Malone University |
| Nate Armstrong | Football | 1995 | All-American | Westminster (Pa.) |
| Nate Arnold | Football | 1995 | All-American | Findlay (Ohio) |
| Nate Weihrauch | Football | 1995 | All-American | Findlay (Ohio) |
| Orlando Joseph | Football | 1995 | All-American | Harding (Ark.) |
| Orlando Steinauer | Football | 1995 | All-American | Western Washington |
| Orlandor Joseph | Football | 1995 | All-American | Harding (Ark.) |
| Park Rice | Football | 1995 | All-American | Rocky Mountain College |
| Pat Schoenen | Football | 1995 | All-American | Western Montana |
| Paul Hladky | Football | 1995 | All-American | Montana Technological University |
| Paul Snow | Football | 1995 | All-American | Western Montana |
| Pete Spratt | Football | 1995 | All-American | Southeastern Oklahoma |
| Phil Porter | Football | 1995 | All-American | University of Sioux Falls |
| Ray Long | Football | 1995 | All-American | Findlay (Ohio) |
| Ray Nealy | Football | 1995 | All-American | Arkansas-Pine Bluff |
| Rich Ferris | Football | 1995 | All-American | Western Montana |
| Rich Haczynski | Football | 1995 | All-American | Concordia (Wis.) |
| Rick Kadrlik | Football | 1995 | All-American | Minot State University |
| Rob Thomas | Football | 1995 | All-American | Bethany College |
| Rocky Reeves | Football | 1995 | All-American | Northeastern Oklahoma State |
| Scott Pratt | Football | 1995 | All-American | Northeastern Oklahoma State |
| Sean Gray | Football | 1995 | All-American | University of the Cumberlands |
| Sean Sharpe | Football | 1995 | All-American | Central State (Ohio) |
| Sean Witherwax | Football | 1995 | All-American | Howard Payne (Texas) |
| Shane Sommerfeld | Football | 1995 | All-American | Dickinson State University |
| Shane Sommerfield | Football | 1995 | All-American | Dickinson State University |
| Shawn Bennett | Football | 1995 | All-American | Hastings College |
| Shawn Chesteen | Football | 1995 | All-American | Westmar (Iowa) |
| Shayne Henderson | Football | 1995 | All-American | Western Montana |
| Shea Little | Football | 1995 | All-American | Eastern Oregon University |
| Steve Clooten | Football | 1995 | All-American | Mary (N.D.) |
| Steve Turella | Football | 1995 | All-American | Puget Sound (Wash.) |
| Teka Brown | Football | 1995 | All-American | Central State (Ohio) |
| Tim Rogers | Football | 1995 | All-American | Campbellsville University |
| Tim Vitito | Football | 1995 | All-American | Southeastern Oklahoma |
| Tommy Thomas | Football | 1995 | All-American | Western Montana |
| Tony Harper | Football | 1995 | All-American | Northwestern Oklahoma State University |
| Tony Hutson | Football | 1995 | All-American | Northeastern Oklahoma State |
| Tony Spencer | Football | 1995 | All-American | Carroll College |
| Ty Starkel | Football | 1995 | All-American | Montana Technological University |
| Tyree Myles | Football | 1995 | All-American | Southwestern College |
| Tyrone Malone | Football | 1995 | All-American | Lambuth University |
| Wade Gebers | Football | 1995 | All-American | Western Washington |
| William Collins | Football | 1995 | All-American | Dana College |
| William Schale | Football | 1995 | All-American | Northwestern Oklahoma State University |
| Willie Murray | Football | 1995 | All-American | Geneva (Pa.) |
| Yohance Brown | Football | 1995 | All-American | Southwestern Oklahoma State |
