| 9/7/24 |
 Bluefield College |
W 31-9 |
Mitchell Stadium – Bluefield, VA |
| 9/14/24 |
 University of Pikeville |
W 52-20 |
James H. Taylor, II Stadium – Williamsburg, KY |
| 9/21/24 |
 Reinhardt University |
L 31-35 |
Ken White Field at University Stadium – Waleska, GA |
| 9/28/24 |
 Union Commonwealth University |
W 28-0 |
James H. Taylor, II Stadium – Williamsburg, KY |
| 10/5/24 |
 Bethel University |
L 17-28 |
Walter Butler Stadium – McKenzie, TN |
| 10/12/24 |
 Lindsey Wilson College |
W 18-14 |
James H. Taylor, II Stadium – Williamsburg, KY |
| 10/19/24 |
 Faulkner University |
W 26-21 |
Billy D. Hilyer Stadium – Montgomery, AL |
| 10/26/24 |
 Cumberland University (TN) |
L 25-49 |
James H. Taylor, II Stadium – Williamsburg, KY |
| 11/2/24 |
 Georgetown College |
L 16-19 |
Toyota Stadium – Georgetown, KY |
| 11/16/24 |
 Campbellsville University |
L 7-47 |
James H. Taylor, II Stadium – Williamsburg, KY |
