| 9/7/24 |
 Concordia Ann Arbor |
L 10-34 |
Cardinal Stadium – Ann Arbor, MI |
| 9/14/24 |
 University of Saint Francis (IN) |
L 36-64 |
Kevin Donley Field at Bishop John M. D’Arcy Stadium |
| 9/21/24 |
 Judson University |
W 38-20 |
Justin F. Coressel Stadium – Defiance, OH |
| 9/28/24 |
 Siena Heights University |
L 7-52 |
Justin F. Coressel Stadium – Defiance, OH |
| 10/5/24 |
 Manchester (Ind.) |
W 35-3 |
Justin F. Coressel Stadium – Defiance, OH |
| 10/12/24 |
 Saint Xavier University |
L 14-45 |
Bruce R. Deaton Memorial Field – Chicago, IL |
| 10/19/24 |
 Rose-Hulman (Ind.) |
L 25-29 |
Cook Stadium – Terre Haute, Indiana |
| 10/26/24 |
 Madonna University |
W 55-27 |
Justin F. Coressel Stadium – Defiance, OH |
| 11/2/24 |
 Taylor University |
L 12-63 |
Turner Stadium – Upland, IN |
| 11/9/24 |
 Hanover (Ind.) |
L 7-31 |
Justin F. Coressel Stadium – Defiance, OH |
| 11/16/24 |
 Bluffton University |
W 23-21 |
Alumni Field – Blufton, OH |
